Many years ago, when still fairly new to the complex world of people management, I found myself in an uncomfortable communication challenge with one of my staff. Fortunately for both of us, I was lucky enough to have a very wise boss.
The challenge was this: my staff member was reaching that restless in-between place where she wanted more responsibility and opportunity but still needed more experience to develop and refine the required skill set. She needed coaching. But she was reluctant to receive my coaching because she perceived it as correcting or criticizing or felt that I didn’t trust her abilities. So after trudging through a couple of frustrating and tense workweeks with one another, rather than the fun, laid-back and supportive style we usually shared, I went off to seek some advice from my boss.
After explaining the situation to him, he instructed me to “Make a deal with her. If she wants to advance her job scope and responsibility then she needs to be willing to receive your advice and coaching to get there. She needs to embrace this as an opportunity and understand that when you coach her it’s intended to be a productive sharing of your experience and skills. And by accepting your advice, observations and experience, she is better equipped to achieve her goals. It’s a simple social contract. If she doesn’t like the terms then she can always leave.”
His abruptness took me by surprise, but he didn’t say it to be harsh. He simply meant that if any team member couldn’t agree to receive clear, honest feedback in order to improve and advance, then they were working in the wrong organization.
So I sat down with my staff member for a heart to heart. I told her that she was very good at what she did and that we wanted her to stay with us and develop her skills further. I also told her that I was very willing to help her become her best. And I told her that the plan had only two conditions: 1) if you want to improve you need to be open to receiving coaching; and 2) we need to be candid about the process and tell each other the truth.
This candor led to a constructive and honest conversation about what style of feedback and coaching she processed best, what tips she had already put into practice and the specific areas in which we both felt she needed to improve. It was positive, productive and paved the way for more honest and candid conversations. And it made us a stronger team.
While I first faced this situation almost 20 years ago, I’ve since used my boss’s advice on many jobs with many staff. It’s helped me maintain a truthful and open relationship with my project teams and they’ve always embraced the chance to be coached honestly and respectfully.
So the next time you’re worried about a potentially difficult conversation with one of your team, invite them to enter into a social contract with you – to listen, to learn and to respect and honour each other with the truth. Contracts don’t get any simpler than that.
Sign up for the weekly “Truth Tuesdays” blog or for a daily dose of truth, click here: .
Great post Mo. Just the other day I was coaching a client about this very thing. A relationship with a colleague was poor, with lots of assumptions being made (but not being tested!). I asked him what his commitments were to the relationship and what he expected in return from his colleague. He realized then that he needed to also ask his colleague what his needs and expectations were (novel isn’t it, this asking, curious conversation thing?). My feedback to my client was that it sounded like he needed to re-contract with his colleague around their relationship. It can be a powerful conversation — especially when it comes with a strong dose of the truth!
Thanks Erin. You comment struck a nerve as this week’s blog started out about the danger of assumptions but morphed into this. I’ll have to tackle assumptions soon!
Looking forward to your next post as well.
Cheers, Mo